Fake recovery

I hate to piss on your parade, but there is no genuine economic recovery happening.

What's going on is:

1) A moderate consumer rebound fueled by deadbeats getting free rent

2) A market bubble fueled by zero interest rates

3) GDP growth driven by horrific deficit spending

On the first point, I wrote last May:
[H]ow much of a stimulative effect is there on the economy when 9% of mortgage debtors suddenly save the $1000 - $2000 per month they used to be wasting on a mortgage? Honey, I stopped paying the mortgage! Let's go to Disney World!
That view is making headlines now, including from CNBC's Diana Olick and Gluskin Sheff's David Rosenberg. I'd add that perpetually extended unemployment benefits, 40 million Americans on food stamps, and "tax credits" for people who don't pay taxes contribute as well.

On the second point, the Fed has proven that it can create asset bubbles better than it can create consumer inflation. The Fed is throwing around so much free money that all risky assets rise (stocks, junk bonds, oil, gold, real estate, etc.). It's not flowing through to consumer inflation much yet because demand is still weak. The Fed is enriching the already rich (asset owners) while doing nothing for the unemployed and underemployed. Asset bubbles don't necessarily create mass employment. See Robert Reich re: there ain't no jobs. Also see Mish on big business hiring:
Here is a snapshot of IBM's US headcount:

2005 133,789
2006 127,000
2007 121,000
2008 115,000
2009 105,000
2010 98,000 estimate

These are all good paying jobs that can support a family and pay taxes.

Today, 75% of the total headcount is overseas. The overseas revenue is 65%. The company reported record profits last year. IBM decided to stop reporting their US headcount this year.

and small business hiring.

On the third point, yes, GDP is rising. What else would you expect when the government is running deficits of 10% of GDP?

GDP = C + I + G + X

Meaning GDP = Consumption + business Investment + Government spending + net eXports

Notice that government spending goes 100% directly into GDP. So if the government hires 1,000 bureaucrats at $100,000 a year to sit around and dream up new ways to torment taxpayers, that's $100 million directly into GDP. Which is exactly what Barack Obama has done, only it isn't $100 million, it's hundreds of billions. Now if you run deficits of 10% of GDP, or more than a trillion dollars a year, all that money goes directly to GDP no matter how wastefully it is spent. Current GDP growth is not a sign of recovery, it's the direct mathematical result of spending our children into debt.

We'll have a real economic recovery when businesses, not government, start hiring. We'll have a real economic recovery when we get GDP growth without running Greece-sized deficits. I hope that recovery comes before Obama has spent us into an inescapable black hole of debt.


T-Dub said...

B.O. sez that if we just crush the USD with our deficit spending, then we can export our way out of this problem.

Good luck with that...

SarahB said...

EXACTLY!!! I can't decide if we are super savvy for sinking our cash into a home purchase this month before hyper inflation hits...or morons for not waiting another 6-12 months when the whole house of cards crumbles and homes are a steel (except for the part where agents will only sell homes to cash investors and normal families are SOL anyway).

Doo Doo Econ said...

All the money is going to "too big to fail" companies, so there is no innovation happening or jobs being created in growth sectors.

The future of the country is squarely upon the shoulders of the Tea Party Movement. I could fix the entire economy for a generation in a week.

reddog said...

I couldn't agree with you more. The question is how long can the false euphoria continue. The last episode lasted half a century, at least. I thought America would never recover from Vietnam, the Great Society and collapse of the Rust Belt in the 70's. Turned out to be only a momentary sputter. Even a relatively minor resurgence could last five years or more. A couple of years ago, I thought we'd be digging ourselves out of the rubble of Western civilization by now. Seems a little premature now.

Economic prognostication is always a crap shoot and crap shooters rarely die rich, at least the ones I know. It's the guy that runs the game that usually does alright. Maybe we should all be buying banking stocks.

W.C. Varones said...


Congratulations, I think.

We struggled with the same issue and also came down on the side of purchasing due to the likely coming inflation.

FrackWit said...

Deadbeats getting free rent, eh? That describes Congress too.

The disinformation and election interference is coming from inside the house

The FBI just admitted in court that Hunter Biden's laptop is real. Here are 20 minutes of Joe Biden, U.S. intelligence officials, and th...